Just say NO

I knew a colleague who believed she should never say no to her twins. She also told me a story about a grocery visit with them that had her walking out in tears without anything to show for her troubles. I was tempted to say, “how’s that working for you”, but didn’t think it would be kind.

From day one my son heard the word no. How else would he learn about boundaries? No isn’t a bad word. It simply conveys that something isn’t right. Maybe he or she is climbing and could fall or has a choking hazard or is about to stick their finger in an electrical outlet. What do I do at that moment? Formulate a sentence without the word no in it! By that time my child is seriously injured or dead.

Think about it this way. If a child hasn’t heard the word no, what happens when he or she hears it for the first time? Emotionally, how will they internalize this? We are supposed to prepare them for the world and guess what, they will hear the word no many times.

We need to prepare them to deal with it in whatever shape or form negativity presents itself. Not saying no to your child isn’t protecting them but insulating them from the real world. What will they do when they get out there?



This text is taken from montessoriparenting.org.   Dr. Montessori famously and repeatedly stated that the child is his own teacher as he explores his world; however, he still needs the adults, from parents to family, teachers, and friends, to be his guides. We are to provide explanations, and boundaries, act as role models; and, at time, be the control that inhibits dangerous, undesirable or inappropriate behavior, to redirect the child’s energies or to deny him something he wants. More often than we might like, this does mean saying “no” to the child.

Psychology Today outlines when to say no to your child. 
1. Say no when their actions might hurt someone or break something.  Preventing harm is the number one reason to say no.

2. Say no when they could do it on their own.  Sometimes kids ask parents to do things for them that they could do on their own.

3. Say no when it’s a want, not a need.   We’re constantly bombarded with ads but buying everything that appeals isn’t the right way to go. 

4. Say no when plans change. Life happens. Even when we intend to do something our children want, sometimes circumstances prevent it from happening.

5. Say no when someone else’s needs (temporarily) matter more.  Kids are naturally self-centered, but considering someone else’s needs enables them to move past that. This kind of no helps children learn generosity.

6. Say no when you’ll resent doing something.  Resentment is poison in any relationship. It’s usually better not to do something than to do it with bitterness and anger. This kind of no helps children learn about healthy boundaries or compromise.

7. Say no when it’s against your values. We teach our children about our values through the choices we make.

There is absolutely nothing wrong with saying no to your child if it’s done with love.  Let them know that even with that no, you love them more than anything else in the world. 

How to say no to say no to your child

I came across this article in Psychology Today called Soft Criticism – The art of gentle correction — it’s not about offering praise. I find it can be used to say no in a way that keeps your child (or adult) calm and receptive.

1. Offer an excuse – “You can’t have that because mommy is using it right now”.  It gives the child a better understanding of why you are saying no and helps calm them down. If not, go to the Tantrums page on this website. 

2. Explain the problem. “You can’t stick your finger in there because you’ll get hurt and mommy will be very sad.” If you get a “Why?”. “Because mommy loves you very much”. If you get another “Why?” . Well, let’s just say you might be there for a while but at least he/she isn’t even thinking of sticking a finger in that outlet anymore.

3. Move forward. Distraction, Distraction, Distraction. This is my favorite and most utilized option. “Why don’t we go play with your toy”. Or maybe you can try a quick pivot. “Oh look a puppy”. Of course, this will not work unless there is an actual puppy. If there isn’t, please refer to the Tantrums page on this website. 

Read more